Author: Dhulfikar
-
Length: Standard read (5-15min)
The Authenticity and Transmission of Ziyarat Ashura
Ziyārat ʿĀshūrā holds a central place in Twelver devotional practice, yet questions remain regarding its chain of transmission and historical origins. A careful examination of the available evidence, key transmitters, and scholarly assessments helps determine how reliably this famous text can be traced back to the Imams (AS). Read more →
-
Length: Quick Read (under 5min)
Was everything the Prophet said “Wahi” as per 53:3-4?
Many Muslims assume that everything spoken by the Prophet (SAW) was divine revelation. Yet the Qur’an distinguishes between revelation, personal judgment, and human experience in several places. Examining these distinctions is essential to understanding the Prophet’s role and how his words should be understood within the broader framework of Islam. Read more →
-
Length: Standard read (5-15min)
What is the status of Aliyyun Waliyullah in the Adhan?
The phrase “ʿAliyyun Walīyullāh” is widely recited today as a third testimony in the adhān, yet its origins remain a subject of debate. Examining the historical evidence, early Shia sources, and scholarly opinions raises important questions about when this practice emerged and whether it formed part of the original call to prayer. Read more →
-
Length: Quick Read (under 5min)
Are deeds not accepted without Wilayat?
The narration often cited to prove that deeds are not accepted without wilāyah rests heavily on a narrator whose reliability has been seriously questioned by prominent Twelver scholars. A closer look at the chain of transmission, the narrator himself, and the report’s theological implications raises important doubts about using it as a foundation for doctrine. Read more →
-
Length: Research Study (30+ min)
Is Istighatha (invoking other than Allah) considered Shirk?
Many people call upon prophets, imams, or other righteous figures believing they can help bring them closer to Allah. The Qur’an, however, repeatedly calls believers to direct their prayers and requests to Allah alone. This raises an important question: does invoking others alongside Allah conflict with pure tawḥīd? Read more →
-
Length: Deep Dive (15-30min)Tags: Ghayb
Ilm al Ghayb of the Prophet (s) and the Aimmah (as)
The Qur’an repeatedly emphasizes that knowledge of the unseen belongs to Allah alone, except for what He chooses to reveal. Claims that the Prophet (SAW) and the Aimmah (AS) possessed unrestricted knowledge of all things invite careful examination in light of the Qur’an, early teachings, and the historical development of doctrine. Read more →
-
Length: Standard read (5-15min)
How and why were the narrations from the Aimmah (as) fabricated?
The Imams (AS) repeatedly warned that fabrications had been attributed to them, just as false reports had been attributed to the Prophet (SAW) before them. Recognizing the existence of fabricated narrations, understanding the motives behind them, and applying clear standards of verification are essential steps in preserving the integrity of their teachings. Read more →
-
Length: Standard read (5-15min)Tags: Ghuluww
What is Ghuluww (Exaggeration) in Religion?
Ghuluww refers to exceeding the limits set by Allah in matters of belief and religion, often by attributing qualities, powers, or ranks to individuals beyond what revelation supports. While motivated by love, reverence, or devotion, such exaggeration has historically altered religious understanding and blurred the distinction between the Creator and His creation. Read more →